Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity and Multiple Chemical Sensitivity:
two sides of the same coin?
several countries EHS, MCS and fibromyalgia are already classified as
Several experts from different European countries agree that Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity is a real, physical illness and for some of them this condition seems to be strictly related to Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS). This is what came out of the congress **Mobile Telephony, Wi-Fi, Wi-Max: Are there Health Risks??** http://international-emf-alliance.org/images/pdf/Congress_EMF_AMICA_2011.pdf, held at Palazzo Marini – Chamber of Deputees in Rome on 14 June 2011. The event, organized by the Association for Environmental and Chronic Toxic Injury (A.M.I.C.A.), was meant to give an overview on the health dangers linked to the use of wireless devices
Prof. Belpomme speaks about MCS and EI
Dominique Belpomme, Oncologist, Professor of the Centre Hospitalier
Universitaire Necker-Enfants Malades, Chairman of Research for
Anti-Cancer Therapeutics (ARTAC), in his lecture **Diagnostic
and Therapeutic Protocols for Electromagnetic Fields Intolerance**,
showed the results of a clinical observation on more than 450
patients enrolled from 2008 to 2011. He and his team use a new
technique to make the diagnosis to people reporting reactions to
electromagnetic fields, a condition that he prefers to define as
rather than **Electromagnetic Hyper-Sensitivity**.
The new technique is the **Pulsed
the brain that combines the eco-doppler with a computer to evaluate
Unlike some other methods, this one is not dangerous and it does not
involve any ionizing radiation. The results show that people with
have a reduced perfusion in the brain, particularly in the left part
of the limbic area of the brain, compared to the control group. This
is a very particular area, because it is the **ancient** part of the
brain that controls many body functions.
**These results are very important – Belpomme said at the congress – because for the first time we are able to define the Electromagnetic Fields Intolerance as a physical illness based on objective tests**.
His team uses also other tests, such as the dosage of histamine, of protein S100B, and of heat shock proteins hsp70 and hsp27 in the blood. The 70% of the group of patients observed showed a serious reduction of vitamin D, about 1-2% of the patients showed an increase of proteins hsp27 and hsp70, while more than the 40% of the sample had increased histamine, a fact that is fully compatible with a physiological interpretation of this syndrome.
About 10% of the patients had an increased protein S100B, which is a marker for Blood Brain Barrier (BBB) permeability. In one third of the sample, a reduction of melatonin in urine was found, and this can explain symptoms such as fatigue, insomnia and depression in these patients.
These alterations are quite similar to the ones found in patients with Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (MCS) http://www.csn-deutschland.de/DIMDI_MCS_2008_de-en.pdf, particularly regarding the brain perfusion reduction, the neurogenic inflammation, the oxidative stress increase, and the reduction of the defense mechanism. The fact that EMF induces the opening of the BBB may interfere with the brain protection from toxic chemicals. It is not uncommon, in fact, that patients with EFI Syndrome have MCS symptoms, while many patients with MCS also react to EMF.
The increase of oxidative stress in electrosensitive patients was found also by Dr. Valeria Pacifico, who lectured in Rome about **Metabolic biomarkers of oxidation-reduction imbalance and susceptibility to non-ionizing radiation**. She works in the team of Dr. Chiara De Luca at the Experimental Laboratory BILARA at Istituto Dermopatico of Immaculata in Rome that published several works on the role of oxidative stress in environmental sensitivities. (1, 2)
**To make a diagnosis of this syndrome we need to listen first to patients and we need to verify if the symptoms improve or disappear when they stay away from EMF sources**, Prof. Belpomme explained. In order to demonstrate if the electromagnetic fields were the real cause of the alterations found in these patients, the patients had to repeat the tests before and after a period of avoidance of EMF for three months. The results show that after the period of avoidance the levels tend toward the normal standard.
Given the strong correlation found by six epidemiologic studies on EMF exposure and Alzheimer Disease (AD), Prof. Belpomme believes that any electrosensitive patient with memory dysfunctions should be evaluated also for AD. He stresses the fact that AD is a loss of long term memory while EFI Syndrome often involves the loss of short term memory, but this symptom may be considered as a pre-Alzheimer condition.
Prof. Olle Johansson, Assoc. Prof., The Experimental Dermatology Unit, Department of Neuroscience, Karolinska Institute; Professor, The Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, talked in Rome about **The precautionary principle: from Bioinititive to the Seletun consensus**. He dedicated his lecture to people affected by EHS and MCS because **they have a very difficult life**.
He is one of the most dedicated scientists in the promotion of new biologically-based safety guidelines for EMF. He was in Benevento for the ICEMS resolution in 2006, then in London in 2007 for a new resolution, and he was also member of the group of independent scientists that published the famous Bioinitiative Report in 2007, which had strong ecological concern in the political agenda. Thanks to this report, in fact, the European Parliament signed a resolution on September 4, 2008 to state that the actual safety limits for EMF are obsolete and to warn EU governments about the increase of new environmental illnesses such as EHS, MCS and Dental Amalgam Mercury Syndrome.
More recently, Prof. Johansson was part of the group of scientists who prepared the Seletun Consensus, published last February in Reviews on Environmental Health (3). It states that present standards do not protect global human population from electromagnetic fields and all EMF should be reduced now instead of waiting for a definitive proof of danger. It also states that people reporting EHS symptoms should be considered as having a functional disability.
In Sweden, for example, EHS, MCS and fibromyalgia are already classified as functional disabilities. This means that people affected by these conditions are not considered patients, but it’s the environment that creates limitations for them so it’s the environment that has to be changed. This kind of classification represents the full concretization of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, signed by governments on March 30, 2007. This convention should be enough to push all governments to find the right accommodation and the best welfare strategies for people with environmental sensitivities, and put an end to discrimination.
Author: Francesca Romana Orlando, journalist and Vice President of A.M.I.C.A. http://lnx.infoamica.it/
Luca C. et al., Biological definition of multiple chemical
sensitivity from redox state and cytokine profiling and not from
polymorphisms of xenobiotic-metabolizing enzymes, Toxicology and
Applied Pharmacology, YTAAP-11818; No. of pages: 8; 4C.
2.De Luca C. et al., The Search for Reliable Biomarkers
of Disease in Multiple Chemical Sensitivity and Other Environmental
Intolerances, Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2011, 8,
3.Fragopoulou A ed al., Scientific panel on electromagnetic field health risks: consensus points, recommendations, and rationales, Rev Environ Health. 2010 Oct-Dec; 25(4):307-17.